So, when Gmaps-Pedometer came onto the scene, I thought “That was it, what could EVER top the coolness of this”. But over the past couple months I’ve seen more and more bike/mapping mashups and I have had a hard time deciding which one to use and which one is the best…hopefully this breakdown will help folks out when choosing how to document their route for their friends:
Gmaps-Pedometer: Originally started out as a running-route mashup, but it’s popularity quickly spread into the biking community. It is, I believe, the first and probably the oldest route-creation mashup out there. However, it’s been showing its age by not having any major updates to keep up with the state of the art. The biggest drawback is that routes are stored via a RouteID which doesn’t really allow you to search for routes in a particular area or to quickly go back to a route you previously created. However, the one saving grace is that it’s quick and easy (no login credentials required to create a route) to create/save a route but you had better remember the URL because once you leave the page, it’s lost forever. It does have elevation and calories burned but I’m not really impressed by those features.
Bikely: This was the second route mash-up that I found and is currently my favorite. Bikely has gone through some minor changes over the months to help ease the pain in creating/storing new routes and bookmarking favorite routes. I like the search feature where you can simply type in a zip code or city/state and it brings up a list of routes. Once one a particular route you it suggests other routes nearby…and will overlay those two routes. Very slick, very hip.
RouteSlip: I think RouteSlip wins in terms of asthetics/presentation, but is slower and harder to use than Bikely. In order to “Discover Routes” you have to dig down into the country->state->city with no real way to search for a given area. When you get to the city page, it basically lists all the cities that have a route pass through it. Needless to say, there could be so many cities listed it’s hard to pick out Snohomish from Sammamish or Redmond from Renton. If you’re new to an area or don’t really have an idea of what cities are nearby it can be a BIG pain to “discover” new routes. I’ve also noticed that its load time is SUPER slow when you actually find a route of interest. However I do like the elevation profile and I think it’s more accurate than Bikely.
VeloRoutes: The new kid on the block so I really haven’t had that much of a chance to play with it. But it’s less of a route planner and more of a route information gatherer. For Seattle, it can overlay the King County or Snohomish County bike map on top of the Google maps. It also has some pictures/webcams/hill gradient information. I think this is site is definitely novel in its concepts, but not all that practical when you get down to it.
BicycleClimbs: This was started by a guy here at Microsoft which I think is funny since he’s using Google’s mapping API instead of MSFT’s Local API. Regardless of that fact, it’s a neat little tool to help you find some hills in your area. It’s not really all that flexible since it’s listed by “Region” and you have to ask to have your “Region” added, but for those of us in Seattle it is a nice reference tool. I think people have gotten a little carried away in adding hills to the Seattle region and accurately assessing how “hard” (A/B/C scale) the climb is, but it is a niche website so what can ya do?
MapCruncher: Only works with Internet Explorer (boooo) but all it really does is overlap the King/Snohomish/Kitsap/Pierce County bike maps over the MSFT Local APIs. VeloRoutes does pretty much the same thing and it’s cross-browser…so use VeloRoutes instead.
Wayfaring: Not really bike specific so it doesn’t really have any of the features you’d come to expect from a route planner. It doesn’t do elevation and I feel it’s more for the non-bike crowd. Imagine a glorified Gmaps-Pedometer mashup geared more towards people making random maps about random things. In all honesty, the only reason to Gmaps-Pedometer over Wayfaring is the route storage…but other than that it doesn’t have all that much going for it.
NYC Bike Maps: There was a time when I thought I was moving to NYC. However, The F™ changed her mind and now I’ll be moving to SC at some point in the near future (she hopes). When I was assessing the bike-ness of NYC, I happened across this little ditty. NYC specific and, for the most part, the routes are already documented on the NYC Bike Map you can get from the city.
I’d be interested to hear of others, so if you know of any, please pass them along!